Table of Contents
Executive Summary
Generative AI can produce text, images and even novel proteins, and businesses expect it to lift productivity. Early examples are encouraging. But history shows that new technologies often take years to raise productivity, and only after substantial investment and workforce reskilling. Generative AI faces similar hurdles in implementation, as well as effects on jobs and skills, and ethical and governance questions. Its potential is real, but businesses should integrate it carefully and with realistic expectations.
Key Points
- Business impact: generative AI can generate text, images and other content, but its effect on productivity varies across sectors.
- Lessons from history: new technologies can drive productivity, but the full benefits usually take substantial time and investment.
- Workforce change: adopting generative AI requires new skills, including digital literacy and adaptability, and creates AI-specific roles.
- Ethics and governance: responsible use of generative AI requires strong governance to address ethical risks and data privacy.
The Promise of Generative AI
What It Can Do
Generative AI includes large language models and image generators. Language models generate high-quality text and can translate, summarise and answer questions. Some models accept both images and text as inputs. Image generators create images or artwork from text prompts, and specialised models in fields such as biomedicine can design proteins with properties specified in natural language.
Expected Productivity Gains
Businesses can use generative AI to write marketing copy and job descriptions, provide conversational support, summarise long documents, search internal documents to improve knowledge sharing, and power chatbots. Other uses include data entry, analysing large datasets, tracking consumer sentiment, writing software, creating test scripts and identifying common bugs in code. Deloitte Insights suggests the most productive uses will give employees tools that enhance their productivity, knowledge and creativity, driving innovation across the enterprise.
Early Results
Early examples are promising. Schneider Electric is using generative AI to transform business processes and people development. Enbridge, a North American energy company, has used it to improve operations, safety, customer experience and environmental performance, including a generative AI copilot for developers and office staff that sped up delivery.
What History Tells Us
Technology has driven much of the productivity growth of the past 150 years, and the spread of information technology contributed to strong productivity growth in the late 1990s. But the gains have rarely been immediate. New technologies often take years to spread across economies, because they depend on complementary investment in new products, processes and business models, and on reskilling the workforce. Early productivity gains can also mislead, with the full benefit arriving only after a long period of adjustment. And technology-driven productivity growth has not been continuous: economists have long noted periods, such as the slowdown that followed the early 1970s, when productivity growth disappointed despite rapid technological change.
Generative AI may follow the same pattern. Its adoption could face similar delays and require substantial investment in infrastructure and skills, which should temper expectations of instant productivity gains.
The Reality Behind Generative AI and Productivity
Where Gains Fall Short
Generative AI does not always raise productivity:
- Outputs often need extensive human correction and refinement, which can cancel out the time saved.
- Large datasets and computing resources make it expensive to run, especially for smaller businesses.
- For some tasks, the need for human oversight negates the efficiency of automation.
- In creative industries, AI-generated content often lacks nuance and originality, so many prefer traditional methods.
Implementation Challenges
- Integration: fitting AI into existing systems and processes is difficult and can create inefficiencies.
- Cost: implementing and maintaining advanced AI can be prohibitive, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises.
- Data: generative AI needs large, diverse, high-quality datasets that many businesses lack.
- Talent: skilled AI professionals are scarce.
- Resistance to change: employees may fear job losses or struggle to adapt to new ways of working.
Why the Gap Persists
The gap between promised and actual gains often comes from a mismatch between AI capabilities and business needs. Overestimating what AI can do leads to unrealistic expectations and disappointing results. Complex systems have a steep learning curve, which delays gains while employees adapt. And a lack of standardisation and interoperability makes it hard to integrate AI into existing workflows.
The Impact on the Workforce
Job Displacement and the Changing Nature of Work
Automation of routine tasks is reducing or eliminating some roles, particularly in manufacturing, customer service and data entry. Higher-skilled work such as analysis and design is also affected, because AI can analyse complex data and generate insights. Demand is growing for digital literacy, problem-solving and adaptability, and new roles are emerging in AI management, development and ethical oversight.
New Skills and the Upskilling Challenge
As AI takes over routine work, skills it cannot easily replicate, such as creative thinking, emotional intelligence and complex problem-solving, become more valuable. Building them requires substantial investment in education and training. Mid-career professionals whose skills are becoming obsolete face the greatest challenge, and organisations and educational institutions need to work together on accessible, relevant learning pathways. Lifelong learning must become the norm, and upskilling must be available to everyone, especially lower-paid workers most at risk of displacement.
Ethics and Governance
Ethical Challenges
- Bias: AI systems learn from data that may contain biases, and can perpetuate stereotypes about race, gender and culture.
- Authenticity and intellectual property: AI-generated content raises questions about originality, ownership and the line between human and machine creativity.
- Misinformation: deepfakes can be used to spread misinformation and manipulate public opinion.
- Deception: realistic, human-like interactions can deceive people and erode trust in digital communication.
Clear guidelines and ethical standards for developing and using generative AI are needed to address these risks.
Governance and Responsible Use
Strong governance means policies for developing and deploying AI ethically and transparently, with particular attention to data privacy, security and the protection of personal information. Clear accountability is needed for any harm that results. Governments, industry and academia should work together on standards and best practice, and public engagement helps ensure governance reflects a broad range of perspectives. Good governance builds public trust in AI.
Conclusion
Generative AI offers real opportunities, but history cautions against expecting immediate gains. Its productivity benefits will depend on long-term integration, deliberate implementation, investment in infrastructure and a workforce ready to use it. Businesses that combine optimism with realism will be best placed to capture its value.
Consulting Interventions
- Generative AI Implementation: Tailored strategies for integrating generative AI into your business to improve efficiency and creative capability.
- Productivity Analysis: Evaluating the impact of generative AI on your operations to maximise productivity gains.
- Custom AI Solutions: Designing bespoke generative AI models for your business needs.
- AI Ethical Frameworks: Ethical guidelines and governance models for responsible AI use.
- Skills Development: Upskilling programs focused on generative AI applications and management.
Merillot helps clients separate the hype from the opportunity and adopt generative AI in ways that deliver measurable productivity gains. Our offerings include: